This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
ACHRNews logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
ACHRNews logo
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Current Issue
    • Digital Edition
    • Archives
    • The NEWS eNewsletter
  • News
    • Breaking News
    • Newsline
    • FYI
    • Distribution Trends
    • Standards & Legislation
    • Manufacturer Reports
  • Products
    • HVACR Industry Store
    • Top 20 Products of 2018
    • Interactive Product Spotlights
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • AHR 2019 Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Infographic
    • Photo Galleries
    • Webinars
    • eBooks
    • The NEWS HVACR Quiz
    • Online Poll
  • Refrigeration
    • Refrigerants
    • Refrigerant Regulations
    • Reclaim
    • FROSTlines
  • Service
    • Testing, Monitoring, Tools
    • Duct Dynasty
    • Service 101
    • Components & Accessories
  • Business 101
    • Training & Education
    • Service, Apps & Software
    • Opinions
    • Guest Column
    • The Coach's Blog
  • Residential
    • Home Automation
    • Residential Ductless
    • Residential Geothermal
    • Residential IAQ
    • Residential Cooling Showcase
    • Residential Heating Showcase
  • Commercial
    • Internet of Things
    • Commercial Ductless
    • Commercial Geothermal
    • Commercial IAQ
    • Commercial Cooling Showcase
    • Commercial Heating Showcase
    • Marijuana Market
  • Directory
    • Manufacturers
    • Wholesalers
    • Consultants/Services
    • Manufacturers Reps
    • Associations
    • Parts & Equipment Exporters
    • List/Update Your Company
  • More
    • Editorial Calendar & Editor Assignments
    • Calendar of Events
    • Classifieds
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • Continuing Education
    • Market Research
    • Sponsor Insights
    • eProduct Info
    • White Papers
    • Contests
  • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Submit a Letter
Home » A Smoldering Problem

A Smoldering Problem

March 11, 2004
Barbara A. Checket-Hanks
Reprints
No Comments
ANAHEIM, Calif. - When it comes to cleaning air that contains environmental tobacco smoke (ETS), there's nothing easy about it. Even discussing the issue can pose difficulties.

For instance, there was a seminar titled "Standard 62's Comfort-Only Approach to Smoking Spaces" at the 2004 Winter Meeting of the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE). The standard addresses comfort considerations in smoking spaces, but not health. Does that do anybody any good?

The real issue seemed to be whether or not you can protect yourself if the building owner decides to offer a smoking environment.

"Can ventilation achieve comfort?" asked moderator Larry Schoen of Schoen Engineering, Columbia, Md. He also announced that the Standard 62 ("Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality") committee removed an appendix on comfort ventilation. It will be included in a design guide.

The addenda are at the heart of the problem. First the smoking space information was re-moved from the standard and stuck in addendum 62o. The addendum contains an appendix that describes a method to achieve comfort, but not any health goals, in smoking spaces.

Now the appendix information is being removed from the addenda and will be included in a design guide. Sadly, moving it will not make the problem of dealing with cigarette smoke go away.

This seminar explored the limitations of the new method in reaching this comfort goal and the remaining health risks that are expected when the addendum is used. It also detailed ASHRAE's response to the dilemma posed by the unavoidable health risks versus the desire to get good information out to the engineering community and the public.

How To Comply

Dennis Stanke is a staff applications engineer for Trane, La Crosse, Wis. He answered his own question, "Can a System with ETS Comply with 62-2001?" You can comply with the standard, logically enough, by following the standard's recommendations, he said. Whether or not the air quality will be good seems debatable, especially within the smoking space itself.

According to Stanke, here is what you need to do to comply with the standard:

  • Assess regional outdoor air quality; survey the local air quality.

  • Meet the minimum requirement for natural ventilation, and provide a balanced ventilation system.

  • Operate exhaust ducts with harmful contaminants at negative pressure. Meet minimum requirements.

  • Use controls to ensure proper ventilation under all conditions.

  • Use materials that resist microbial growth and environmental damage. Design for the local capture of contaminants. For particulate matter removal, apply MERV 6 filtration upstream of wet surfaces. Filter outdoor air using MERV 6 filters in applicable geographic regions. Don't operate the building without filters.

  • Make sure there is sufficient combustion air for combustion appliances.

  • Limit relative humidity to 65 percent or less. Make sure systems have functional drain pans and other means of condensate removal. Select the coils and heat exchanger to prevent moisture carryover. Insulate cold pipes to prevent condensation formation.

  • Identify sources of contaminants in order to deal with them effectively.

  • In structures where "dirty" and "clean" zones share the same building, take necessary steps to keep the air from recirculating from the dirty space into the clean. For instance, practice appropriate garage ventilation precautions. Separate ETS from non-ETS areas, avoid recirculation, and post ETS warning signs. Use the ventilation rate procedure or IAQ procedure to find airflow rates.

    If there are smoking areas, there must be ventilation at a higher rate than nonsmoking areas. You must not recirculate between the two areas. How much more ventilation is needed? Stanke said the standard does not specify the amount.

    Likewise, the standard does not include information on what may constitute an acceptable concentration of ETS. It does specify that the designer sets a target limit and site a "cognizant" authority. "It may be difficult to find one," Stanke said. "You need somebody who has expertise and jurisdiction, or authoritative organization."

  • Develop a building O&M (operations and maintenance) manual.

    According to Stanke, if smoking is permitted throughout the building, the system must meet all requirements in all sections.

    In a mixed-area building, the system must meet all requirements, with the additional requirement that the smoking space cannot return air to the nonsmoking space.

    What the standard advises is the design and maintenance of a building system with possibly a higher degree of filtration, and higher-than-normal ventilation air change rates. "We don't know the resulting outcome in terms of health or comfort due to increased ventilation," said Stanke. "It will comply with the standard.

    "Some people say that you can't comply with Standard 62," he said. "You can if you meet all the requirements. However, you can meet all the requirements and still not do it" - achieve good IAQ, that is.

    Big Health Risks

    James L. Repace of Repace Associates Inc., Bowie, Md., is a health physicist and an expert witness on secondhand smoke. He took issue, first of all, with the idea that there is no cognizant authority on ETS.

    "I'm going to be the cognizant authority for the purpose of this talk," he said. Throughout his presentation, he cited statistics from the National Cancer Institute, NIOSH, U.S. EPA, California EPA, Surgeon General's Office, and the National Toxicology program - "all cognizant experts," he said. "They report 60,000 deaths per year due to secondhand smoke."

    He started with a sobering figure. According to 1998 data, there are 48 million smokers in the United States who die from the effects of smoking at a rate of 430,000 per year.

    The ASHRAE guidelines, he said, suggest that the perception of odor, nonrecirculation, and other recommendations can sufficiently address ETS. This, he said, is not so.

    Measuring The Problem In The Field

    One published study looked at ETS at three separate pubs - one each in Toronto, Wilmington, Del., and Boston. The researchers went with measuring devices and a time stamp.

    The Black Dog Pub in Toronto, Repace said, is an ETS "poster child" for the Canadian hospitality industry. The building allows smoking, and its mechanical system satisfies Standard 62 requirements. On their field trip, the researchers measured respirable ETS particles up to 500 micrograms per cubic meter; mean respirable particles were 200 micrograms per cubic meter.

    The EPA recommended level is 15 micrograms per cubic meter.

    According to expert sources, there are 16 deaths from heart diseases and lung cancer for every 100 workers/100 micrograms of respirable ETS particles/cubic meter, Repace said. "We are way up in the unacceptable load." It would take 100,000 cfm of air/occupant to get ETS particles to an acceptable risk level. Those would be tornado-like levels of ventilation.

    When smoking was still allowed in the Wilmington pub, ETS levels in the pool hall were more than 1,000 micrograms per cubic meter. After the smoking ban, carcinogen levels dropped 95 percent. "You can't do that with ventilation," Repace stated. The Boston pub had similar results before and after smoking bans.

    Repace's message to ASHRAE was simply this: "Cognizant authorities state that ETS kills. Ventilation is not a control for secondhand smoke." It is not expected to be one in any industrial setting.

    Publication date: 03/15/2004

  • Subscribe to The NEWS

    Recent Articles by Barbara Checket-Hanks

    Greenbuild Products Cut a Broad Swath

    Experts Share Anti-Corrosion Techniques

    Building Up Your Employees

    Contractors See Health Care Growth

    LEED for Healthcare Facilities Blends Comfort, IAQ, and Efficiency

    Barbara Checket-Hanks is Service & Maintenance Editor. E-mail her at barbarachecket-hanks@achrnews.com.

    Related Articles

    IAQ Problems On The Rise, Contractor Says

    How to create noise and vibration problems

    Fighting Moisture, Frost, and Ice Problems

    Contractor Solves Problems With Zoning

    You must login or register in order to post a comment.

    Report Abusive Comment

    Subscription Center
    • Subscribe
    • Renew
    • Create Account
    • Change My Address
    • Pay My Bill
    • Free eNewsletters
    • About News Network
    • Customer Care

    More Videos

    Sponsored Content What Is Sponsored Content

    Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the ACHR News audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep.

    Close
    Trane-indoor-air-quality-product-01
    Sponsored By
    Trane Residential

    Protecting Your Customers’ Indoor Air Quality Is More Important Than Ever

    From seasonal maintenance to a system upgrade, your business is actually centered around providing the best indoor air experience, with quality at the core.

    Popular Stories

    Breaking News - The ACHR News

    Ingersoll Rand Increases Prices on HVAC products

    R-22 Phaseout

    Using (or Abusing) the R-22 Phaseout as a Sales Tool

    Senate HFC Phasedown Bill

    Senate HFC Phasedown Plan Debuts With Broad Support

    Breaking News - The ACHR News

    Lennox Industries Inc. Announces Price Increase

    Goodman employees work to manufacture highend equipment.

    The HVAC Contractor’s Guide to High-End Trends Coming in 2020

    The ACHR News Airpod Giveaway

    Events

    September 16, 2020

    2020 World Congress for Solar Cooling

    IASC seeks submissions that represent the best contemporary and innovative technology and thinking about Solar Cooling from a global and diverse range of designers, consultants, practitioners, engineers, architects, educators, thought-leaders, students and other professionals concerned with cooling, people, buildings and energy.
    December 30, 2030

    Webinar Sponsorship Information

    For webinar sponsorship information, visit www.bnpevents.com/webinars or email webinars@bnpmedia.com.

    View All Submit An Event

    Poll

    Holiday Appreciation

    What is your preferred way to show employees your appreciation during the holiday season?
    View Results Poll Archive

    Products

    "More & New" HVAC Spells Wealth - book

    "More & New" HVAC Spells Wealth - book

    See More Products
    The NEWS - ACHR - Logo The NEWS - ACHR - Digital Edition
    Digital Edition

    ACHRNEWS

    The ACHR News - December 2, 2019

    2019 December 2

    Week 1: December 2
    In this issue of The ACHR NEWS, we look at unique applications of HVAC technology, and new markets contractors should consider expanding into.

    Week 2: December 9
    We also examine Variable Refrigerant Flow (VRF) technology, and the benefits that contractors can pass along to their customers through the equipment.

    View More Subscribe
    • Resources
      • Submit a Letter
      • Submit a Press Release
      • Mechanical Group
      • List Rental
      • Ad Specs
      • Reprints
      • eProduct Info
      • Survey And Sample
      • Privacy Policy
    • Want More?
      • Subscribe
      • Connect
    • Subscribe
      • Subscribe
      • Renew
      • Create Account
      • Change Address
      • Pay My Bill
      • Free eNewsletters
      • Customer Care

    Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

    Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing