This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
ACHRNews logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
ACHRNews logo
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Current Issue
    • Digital Edition
    • Archives
    • The NEWS eNewsletter
  • News
    • Breaking News
    • Newsline
    • FYI
    • Distribution Trends
    • Standards & Legislation
    • Manufacturer Reports
  • Products
    • HVACR Industry Store
    • Top 20 Products of 2018
    • Interactive Product Spotlights
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • AHR 2019 Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Infographic
    • Photo Galleries
    • Webinars
    • eBooks
    • The NEWS HVACR Quiz
    • Online Poll
  • Refrigeration
    • Refrigerants
    • Refrigerant Regulations
    • Reclaim
    • FROSTlines
  • Service
    • Testing, Monitoring, Tools
    • Duct Dynasty
    • Service 101
    • Components & Accessories
  • Business 101
    • Training & Education
    • Service, Apps & Software
    • Opinions
    • Guest Column
    • The Coach's Blog
  • Residential
    • Home Automation
    • Residential Ductless
    • Residential Geothermal
    • Residential IAQ
    • Residential Cooling Showcase
    • Residential Heating Showcase
  • Commercial
    • Internet of Things
    • Commercial Ductless
    • Commercial Geothermal
    • Commercial IAQ
    • Commercial Cooling Showcase
    • Commercial Heating Showcase
    • Marijuana Market
  • Directory
    • Manufacturers
    • Wholesalers
    • Consultants/Services
    • Manufacturers Reps
    • Associations
    • Parts & Equipment Exporters
    • List/Update Your Company
  • More
    • Editorial Calendar & Editor Assignments
    • Calendar of Events
    • Classifieds
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • Continuing Education
    • Market Research
    • Sponsor Insights
    • eProduct Info
    • White Papers
    • Contests
  • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Submit a Letter
Home » Union Pension Plans: Financial Risks and Liability Considerations for Employers
Extra EditionBusiness Management

Union Pension Plans: Financial Risks and Liability Considerations for Employers

Business Management - woman
May 21, 2012
Richard D. Alaniz
KEYWORDS multiemployer pension plans / pension fund withdrawal / Unions and HVAC
Reprints
No Comments
Richard Alaniz
Richard D. Alaniz

Along with underfunded corporate and public pensions, many union pensions are massively in the red. For employers who have union workers who participate in these types of multiemployer pension plans, the growing liability involved with withdrawing from pension funds presents a serious issue.

According to the Financial Times, the current shortfall in multiemployer pension plans is $369 billion. Union funds have been hammered by unwise investments and overly generous benefits, which has created significant shortfalls in the amount of money that many pension funds have, versus the amounts they have promised their members.

In 2011, the U.S. Department of Labor issued “critical status” notices meaning that the funding percentage of the plan was 65 percent or less, or that there would be a cash-flow crisis within three to six years, to more than 180 union pension plans. Another 116 plans received “endangered status” notices, meaning that either the funding percentage is 80 percent or less or they face funding deficiencies within the next six years. Plans on the critical and endangered lists are not limited to one industry or only to those plans small in size or participants; they include a range of sizes, industries, and geographic locations.

In an Internal Revenue Service (IRS) newsletter, Monika Templeman, director of employee plan examinations, pointed to several funding issues that IRS agents find when they examine multiemployer pension funds, including several employer-related ones. “The issues occurring most often include trustees not pursuing receipt of delinquent contributions from employers, diversion of trust assets, and trustees not assessing withdrawal liability to withdrawing employers or not assessing it in a timely manner,” she said.

Considering the funding shortfalls, uncertain economy, and federal government’s emphasis on ensuring that employers be assessed and pay any withdrawal liability, companies should be on notice of possible consequences if they completely or even partially withdraw from union pension funds.

Pension Fund Withdrawals

Multiemployer pension funds are required to collect withdrawal liability amounts from employers when companies terminate or decrease their contribution obligations for any reason. Essentially, it’s an “exit penalty” assessed against employers. The fiduciaries of the plan determine how much the liability is, notify the employer of that amount, and then collect the liability, using lawsuits if necessary.

Withdrawals from union pension plans can be extraordinarily expensive. In 2007, it cost UPS $6.1 billion to withdraw from the Central States Pension Plan, after the ratification of a long-term national master agreement with the International Brotherhood of Teamsters.

There are several different types of withdrawals that trigger liability, including complete, partial, and mass:

• Complete withdrawal

Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), a complete withdrawal occurs when the employer permanently ceases to have an obligation to contribute to the plan or permanently ceases all covered operations under the plan. The law does offer some protection to an employer that temporarily suspends contributions during a labor dispute with its workers, such as strikes and lockouts.

• Partial withdrawal

Some employers may consider gradually decreasing their contributions to a multiemployer pension plan. However, ERISA rules have taken that into consideration, and a partial withdrawal can trigger liability. A partial withdrawal occurs when the employer’s “contribution base units” decline by 70 percent or more, or the employer partially ceases their contribution obligations.

• Mass withdrawal

A mass withdrawal takes place when all the contributing employers withdraw from a plan and the plan is terminated. Employers who withdrew within three years of the termination will still be considered part of the mass withdrawal for liability purposes.

Taking Shelter in a Recent Court Ruling

For employers looking to withdraw from union pensions with a minimum of exposure, the options have been very limited. However, a recent court ruling offers some hope. In Shelter Distribution, Inc. v. General Drivers, Warehousemen & Helpers Local Union No. 89, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled there is nothing in the law that prohibits employers from including an indemnification clause against withdrawal liability in a collective bargaining agreement (CBA) with a union.

In that case, Shelter and the union agreed as part of the CBA that the union would “indemnify the Company for any contingent liability which may be imposed” under the Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendments Act [MPPAA].” According to the language of the agreement, Shelter would still have to pay the withdrawal liability, but it could then seek reimbursement from the union.

During negotiations for the next CBA, the union disclaimed representation of Shelter’s employees and terminated the collective-bargaining process. Shelter then withdrew from the pension plan, The Central States, Southeast and Southwest Areas Health and Welfare and Pension Fund, which charged a withdrawal liability of $57,291.50 against Shelter. Shelter paid, then demanded indemnification according to the terms of the CBA, which the union refused to pay.

During arbitration, the union claimed that the indemnification clause was void when the CBA expired and that the provision for arbitration was unenforceable because it violated public policy. The arbitrator rejected both arguments, and the union took the matter to court. The district court agreed with the arbitrator. However, on appeal, the Sixth Circuit ruled that the indemnification clause did not violate public policy, finding that the primary goals of MPAAA and ERISA could still be served even in light of such an indemnification agreement.

What to Do Now

In the face of massively underfunded union pensions and burdensome legislation, companies need to understand the financial implications involved with multiemployer pension plans and withdrawal liability, whether their employees vote to unionize, the company purchases a company with unionized employees, creates a unionized division to bid for union work, or takes any actions that could trigger a complete or partial withdrawal from a union fund.

• The Implications of Participating in a Multiemployer Fund or Entering into a CBA

Before beginning contributions to a multiemployer union pension fund, employers need to understand what is involved in leaving one, and have a solid exit strategy in place. Withdrawal penalties can be extremely expensive, and payments can drag on for years. When companies consider different scenarios that could lead to union pension fund contributions, they should consult with outside counsel who understand the issues and can explain exactly what the business and financial implications will be, and how the company can best protect itself.

When companies are entering into a new CBA, they should carefully consider the ruling in the Shelter case. That ruling only stands in the Sixth Circuit, but arbitrators and other courts may consider it when ruling in similar situations. Companies should make indemnification clauses a very high priority during negotiations, if there is even a chance they may withdraw from the pension fund before the next CBA. The language of these provisions should be explicit, and should specifically state that the duty to indemnify extends beyond the expiration of the CBA.

Some companies create “double-breasted” operations, where one group is unionized and one is not. While this allows employers to provide both a union and non-union workforce, it can create union pension exposure. The non-union part of the company can get sucked into the pension obligations of the union counterpart. Companies should look very closely at how the ownership and financial controls are structured, how management is involved in both areas, and how integrated the operations are. Companies should work closely with legal counsel and human resources staff to make sure the appropriate level of distance exists between the two companies, which will minimize the risk of withdrawal liability.

• The Implications of Withdrawing From a Plan

Employers may not even have a choice about completely or partially withdrawing from a multiemployer union pension plan. Employees can vote to leave the union, businesses may have to lay off union employees, or the company may merge with another company.

Employers need to carefully monitor changes in union activity, declines in business that could lead to layoffs, or possible mergers and acquisitions. Before entering into any kind of merger, acquisition, or other relationship with a unionized business, employers need to understand if the CBA requires them to contribute to a multiemployer pension plan for union employees. Depending on the answer, the company may want to reconsider the structure of the transaction or even rethink it completely.

Withdrawal liability is expensive and time-consuming. Any company that is involved in multiemployer pension plans needs to understand its exposure to the liability and how best to minimize and manage that exposure.

Publication date: 05/21/2012

Subscribe to The NEWS

Recent Articles by Richard Alaniz

A Guide to Marijuana Legislation, and Its Effect on the Workplace

Understanding Liability for Unpaid Wages

A Quick Look at Unions and Employers

Navigating Workplace Employee Disputes

Understanding How Wage Theft Laws Work

Headshot-richard-alaniz-photo

Richard D. Alaniz, of Alaniz Law and Associates, has been at the forefront of labor and employment law for over 30 years, including stints with the U.S. Department of Labor and the National Labor Relations Board. Alaniz is a prolific writer on labor and employment law and conducts frequent seminars to client companies and trade associations across the country. Questions about this article, or requests to subscribe to receive his monthly articles, can be addressed to Rick at (281) 381-2219 or ralaniz@alaniz-law.com.

 

Related Articles

Payroll Issues, Personal Liability: Employers Paying the Penalty for Wage and Hour Violations

When Violence Affects the Workplace, What Liabilities Do Employers Face?

A Quick Look at Unions and Employers

Watch Out for UFOs: Worker Centers as ‘Union Front Organizers’

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscription Center
  • Subscribe
  • Renew
  • Create Account
  • Change My Address
  • Pay My Bill
  • Free eNewsletters
  • About News Network
  • Customer Care

More Videos

Sponsored Content What Is Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the ACHR News audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep.

Close
Trane-indoor-air-quality-product-01
Sponsored By
Trane Residential

Protecting Your Customers’ Indoor Air Quality Is More Important Than Ever

From seasonal maintenance to a system upgrade, your business is actually centered around providing the best indoor air experience, with quality at the core.

Popular Stories

Breaking News - The ACHR News

Ingersoll Rand Increases Prices on HVAC products

R-22 Phaseout

Using (or Abusing) the R-22 Phaseout as a Sales Tool

Senate HFC Phasedown Bill

Senate HFC Phasedown Plan Debuts With Broad Support

Breaking News - The ACHR News

Lennox Industries Inc. Announces Price Increase

Goodman employees work to manufacture highend equipment.

The HVAC Contractor’s Guide to High-End Trends Coming in 2020

The ACHR News Airpod Giveaway

Events

September 16, 2020

2020 World Congress for Solar Cooling

IASC seeks submissions that represent the best contemporary and innovative technology and thinking about Solar Cooling from a global and diverse range of designers, consultants, practitioners, engineers, architects, educators, thought-leaders, students and other professionals concerned with cooling, people, buildings and energy.
December 30, 2030

Webinar Sponsorship Information

For webinar sponsorship information, visit www.bnpevents.com/webinars or email webinars@bnpmedia.com.

View All Submit An Event

Poll

Holiday Appreciation

What is your preferred way to show employees your appreciation during the holiday season?
View Results Poll Archive

Products

"More & New" HVAC Spells Wealth - book

"More & New" HVAC Spells Wealth - book

See More Products
The NEWS - ACHR - Logo The NEWS - ACHR - Digital Edition
Digital Edition

ACHRNEWS

The ACHR News - December 2, 2019

2019 December 2

Week 1: December 2
In this issue of The ACHR NEWS, we look at unique applications of HVAC technology, and new markets contractors should consider expanding into.

Week 2: December 9
We also examine Variable Refrigerant Flow (VRF) technology, and the benefits that contractors can pass along to their customers through the equipment.

View More Subscribe
  • Resources
    • Submit a Letter
    • Submit a Press Release
    • Mechanical Group
    • List Rental
    • Ad Specs
    • Reprints
    • eProduct Info
    • Survey And Sample
    • Privacy Policy
  • Want More?
    • Subscribe
    • Connect
  • Subscribe
    • Subscribe
    • Renew
    • Create Account
    • Change Address
    • Pay My Bill
    • Free eNewsletters
    • Customer Care

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing