Refrigeration

Considering a CO2 Refrigeration System

Counting Costs and Comparing Options

July 28, 2014
Trans

EDITOR’S NOTE: This article is the first of a two-part series in response to the question: “Should I choose CO2 (R-744) for my refrigeration system?” It was prepared by engineers with M&M Refrigeration (www.mmrefrigeration.com) of Federalsburg, Maryland.

The application of cascade carbon dioxide and ammonia (cascade CO2/NH3) refrigerating systems has been gaining popularity in North America for the past number of years. But to correctly answer the question, “Should I choose CO2 for my refrigeration system?”, one must first identify the objectives for the refrigeration plant.

Some of the questions to ask are:

• What temperature do you need to maintain?

• Are there product freezing requirements?

• Is maintaining a reduced ammonia system charge critical (most systems under 10,000 lbs.)?

• Is having no contaminating refrigerants in the food storage, processing, and employee work areas desirable?

• Is providing a “green” refrigeration system important?

Counting Costs

Obviously cost is always an important factor in any project.

If your project does not require storage temperatures below 0° to -4°F and there is no blast freezing and very little room freezing requirement, the most cost effective and efficient refrigerating system would be a single stage economized ammonia refrigeration system.

However, if your storage temperature requirements are below -4° and there is considerable room and or blast freezing requirements, you should carefully consider the benefits of a cascade CO2/NH3 refrigerating system.

Additionally, depending upon the size of the refrigerated facility, the installed cost of a cascade CO2/NH3 refrigerating system is often less than an equivalent two-stage ammonia system. The primary factors contributing to the lower cost are smaller low stage compressors; smaller low temperature suction piping, valves, and liquid separating vessels; less piping and vessel insulation; and lower CO2 costs.

When lower temperatures than those just mentioned are required, the operating cost of a cascade CO2/NH3 refrigerating system becomes very attractive.

Testing

A third-party energy company conducted a comprehensive study of a cascade CO2/NH3 system modeled against an equivalent two-stage ammonia system. The project included field installed instrumentation and data acquisition equipment to monitor and evaluate the real-time performance of the refrigeration plant. The plant had refrigerated storage spaces, and ultra-low temperature blast freezers that have the ability to operate at temperatures lower than those commonly obtained with conventional ammonia systems.

The cascade CO2/NH3 system operates at the following nominal process temperatures (i.e., saturated temperatures): -58° blast freezing; -20° CO2 freezer storage; +20° CO2 coolers and docks; and +11° NH3 high stage. The conventional ammonia system was model for the following temperatures: -58° NH3 blast freezing; -20° NH3 freezer storage; and +20° NH3 high stage, coolers and docks. The efficiency of the cascade CO2/NH3 refrigerating system was measured in kilowatts per ton of refrigeration load (kW/TR).

After five months of monitored operation the comparison of the cascade CO2/NH3 refrigerating system efficiency to the efficiency calculated for the conventional two-stage ammonia system indicated that the cascade CO2/NH3 combined (-58° and -20° suction groups) efficiency showed a 28.7 percent improvement compared to the conventional ammonia system. However, the cascade CO2/NH3 overall system efficiency was reduced by the cascade heat exchangers between the CO2 compressors’ +20° saturated discharge temperature and the +11° ammonia high stage saturated suction temperature.

Moreover, the cascade CO2/NH3 system showed a 5.8 percent overall efficiency improvement over the conventional ammonia system (Table 1).

Many refrigeration engineers and service technicians have generally reached the opinion that there is very little difference between maintaining a CO2 system compared to an ammonia system.

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to The NEWS Magazine

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Multimedia

Videos

Image Galleries

2014 Energy Efficiency Forum

Highlights from the 25th annual Energy Efficiency Forum in Washington, D.C.

Podcasts

NEWSMakers: Jason Vogelbaugh

Jason Vogelbaugh of Alpha Controls drops in to the NEWSMakers podcast to discuss his role with the company, the InsideIQ Building Automation Alliance, and current energy-efficiency projects being worked on. Posted on Sept. 26.

More Podcasts

ACHRNEWS

NEWS 09-29-14 cover

2014 September 29

Check out the weekly edition of The NEWS today!

Table Of Contents Subscribe

EFFICIENCY STANDARDS

DOE has denied AHRI’s petition for reconsideration of walk-in standards. Is it getting harder to reach consensus on efficiency standards?
View Results Poll Archive

HVACR INDUSTRY STORE

plumbing-hvac.gif
2014 National Plumbing & HVAC Estimator

Every plumbing and HVAC estimator can use the cost estimates in this practical manual!

More Products

Clear Seas Research

 

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications, Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.

DON'T MISS A THING

Magazine image
 
Register today for complete access to ACHRNews.com. Get full access to the latest features, Extra Edition, and more.

STAY CONNECTED

facebook icontwitter iconyoutube iconLinkedIn i con