ACHRNEWS

Ammonia Leak From Rail Car Puzzles Troubleshooters

September 30, 2000
Even proponents of ammonia agree it is not a good idea to have too much of the refrigerant near a residential neighborhood. A recent incident in the small town of Fort Edward, near Albany, NY, gave credence to the concern.

The problem wasn’t a plant. It was a railroad car that just happened to be passing through. It sprung a leak in early September in the town of 1,200. As a result, 800 of the residents had to leave their homes for several days and dozens of experts had to figure out ways to get the situation under control.

The ammonia leaked through a 6-in.-dia valve at the top of the tank car. The gas, which can burn the skin and cause respiratory problems, initially hissed from the apparently faulty valve at the top of the car at more than 170 lb of pressure/sq in., according to one person close to the investigation. In all, there were 22,000 lbs of ammonia in the rail car.



Leak Wouldn’t Freeze

Those troubleshooting the problem originally assumed the ammonia would freeze inside the car and at the valve as the pressure inside the car went down. If the valve had frozen for even a minute, a crew could have replaced it and stopped the leak, on-site personnel said.

Local fire departments covered the tanker with a fine spray of water, trying to keep the ammonia gas fumes contained. That water froze despite the 80°F-plus ambient temperatures.

Why the valve and ammonia didn’t freeze could not be explained. Experts had hoped the freezing would occur at about a 5-lb/sq-in. pressure. That level was reached close to 48 hrs after the leak was first reported.

The next effort involved using nitrogen, an inert, nontoxic, nonexplosive gas. The nitrogen, under pressure, was pumped into the tank car, forcing the liquid ammonia out of the bottom, through pipes, and into a second rail car. The nitrogen filled the top of the car as it was pumped in and bled through the leaking valve, replacing the ammonia that was leaking.

EPA officials on the scene said all readings other than those immediately around the rail car showed levels of ammonia well within the amounts that the government holds to be safe, even with prolonged exposure. Although some 30 to 50 people were initially taken to area hospitals, mostly with breathing complaints, officials reported that none were serious and only the most fragile were held, largely for observation.

A task force of federal, state, and Canadian officials (a Canadian rail carrier transported the ammonia tank car) investigated the cause of the leak, and have released some of their preliminary findings. The Federal Railroad Administration said it is focusing at least part of its investigation on the Trinity Saginaw Facility in Saginaw, TX, where the tanker car last underwent repairs in July. One source close to the investigation said it was the tanker’s first trip since those repairs.

Publication date: 10/02/2000