Hidden Problems Can Cause Carbon Monoxide
Whenever there is a malfunction of either the inlet or outlet system, there is a potential for incomplete combustion, which can result in carbon monoxide (CO) gases.
This article addresses residential gas heating systems with nondedicated combustion air inlets: Those furnaces that are inside the living space without direct communication to the outside air.
(Note: This article is meant to provide a general overview. For more information on testing for CO, read the supplement “Technical Background For Residential Carbon Monoxide Responders” in the National Fuel Gas Code. Also, there are many sites on the Web that have valuable information. And be sure to check with the combustion equipment manufacturers for their specific guidelines.)
Many older homes have furnaces that draw air for combustion from the occupied space. As the furnace pulls this air from the space, it is replenished by air infiltrating the house through windows, doors, and other not-so-obvious openings — at least that was the original intention. This can create a potentially dangerous situation.
Modifications done to the structure can inadvertently inhibit this flow of combustion air, causing the furnace or any other gas appliance to malfunction. Other problems in the house can turn an improperly vented furnace into a CO-generating machine.
Some FundamentalsMost residential furnaces use natural draft to drive the combustion process. Even 80%-AFUE furnaces with combustion blowers are natural-draft furnaces. The combustion blower in an 80% furnace assists the combustion gases, but the flue still operates like a natural-draft furnace: The natural pressure differential created by heating the combustion gases in the furnace is what pushes the flue gases up and out of the flue.
As combustion gases are heated, they expand. This makes them less dense than the colder air entering the furnace, so they weigh less. They also exist at a lower pressure than the colder inlet air.
Since the combustion gases are at a lower pressure, the higher-pressure inlet gases displace them, pushing them up and out the flue (the same way that heavier, higher-pressure beer pushes the lighter, lower-pressure CO2 bubbles up to the top of a glass). For the flue to operate properly, the inlet air must always be at a higher pressure than the combustion gases so that this pressure differential can be maintained.
When this pressure differential is diminished by the flue pressure becoming too positive or the combustion air inlet becoming too negative, air stops drafting through the furnace. That’s when CO is created. And if the furnace is not drafting, the CO ends up staying in the residence.
Depending on the outdoor temperature, the pressure differential needed to drive the flue gases up and out of the furnace is somewhere between 1 and 5 Pascals (0.004 to 0.020 in. of water column, wc). What this means is, as the flue gases leave the furnace, they must be at -1 to -5 Pascals relative to atmospheric pressure. A Pascal is about the weight of a Post-it® note. So you can see that the pressure differential needed to be maintained between the inlet and outlet of the furnace’s combustion air system is very delicate and can be easily disturbed. Anything that will raise the pressure in the flue or lower the pressure in the combustion air inlet system can interrupt the flow of air through the furnace and create carbon monoxide.
Combustion Air InfiltrationWhen a structure has a properly designed combustion air inlet system, the furnace enclosure has two dedicated vents communicating with the outside air, eliminating the need to obtain combustion inlet air from or through the living space.
Residences with a nondedicated combustion air inlet system are the homes that are at risk (see Figure 1). These homes may have worked fine since they were built, but can develop problems as a result of modernization, such as new high-efficiency windows, weather stripping, and general sealing of the structure. Anything that disturbs the pressure in the space can affect the operation of the furnace.
If a house is tightened up for energy conservation, the infiltration rate may be diminished; the house pressure drops as the furnace draws combustion air from the space. Eventually the house pressure can drop enough to reduce the combustion air inlet pressure to a point that the flue will quit drafting. Usually tightening the house alone will not cause a furnace to malfunction, but it can restrict the combustion air inlet to a point where anything that affects house pressure can inhibit furnace venting.
Some other things that can reduce combustion inlet air pressure include:
Field SolutionsSo many variables determine how CO affects the occupants of a home. That’s why CO testing standards and processes differ from one municipality to another. I strongly recommend that you contact your local fire department or gas utility to acquaint yourself with local practices.
Much of the information included in this article comes from the Carbon Monoxide Safety Awareness Advisory Council, and may or may not be used in your area.
There are two general issues that have to be addressed when testing for CO:
1. What is the net indoor ambient CO level in the house when you arrive, and are any gas appliances generating excessive CO during your routine test?
2. Could any latent problems in the home produce CO at another time?
If you work on furnaces, you should have a quality CO tester available. That way, before you enter a house, you can routinely take a CO reading outside to establish a baseline level. Take a CO reading inside the house just as you enter the front door. Subtract the outside CO level from the inside level to obtain the net inside level. If the net CO level in the occupied space is below 9 parts per million (ppm), the space is considered safe.
A CO level of 10 to 35 ppm is considered a marginal health hazard. If I were to discover such a situation, I would immediately call the appropriate emergency response agency (fire department or gas utility) to make sure I was handling the situation per local practices. Check with your company’s management to find out what your CO action policy is.
For any reading above 35 ppm, occupants should exit the building immediately.
Furnace TestingTo test a nonpower-ventilated furnace for CO, place your instrument probe in the outlet of each heat exchanger upstream of the flue diverter box. To test a power-ventilated, 80%- to 90%-plus-AFUE furnace, take your readings in the vent connector 12 to 18 in. from the furnace outlet.
The test should be performed for 5 min. CO levels should not exceed 99 ppm. If they do, shut down the furnace and locate the problem. Don’t forget that the cause could be in the furnace (such as a cracked heat exchanger), in the venting system, or in the combustion air inlet system.
To test a house for latent problems that could cause CO production, you must set up a worst-case scenario to attempt to drop the pressure in the house. This is a test you could use to check a house that did not have properly designed combustion air inlet.
(Note: The following is a summary only, meant to provide an overview of the testing concept. This test should not be performed by inadequately trained personnel or those without a properly operating CO meter.)
1. Turn off all gas appliances such as furnaces, water heaters, ovens, stoves, and any other fossil fuel-burning devices; leave the pilots on.
2. Close all exterior openings in the house, such as doors, windows, attic access, and fireplace dampers.
3. Close all doors to rooms that have a supply register but no return register, except those rooms that have exhaust fans.
4. Close the furnace and hot water heater enclosure door, if any.
5. Turn on furnace blower(s).
6. Turn all exhaust fans on high, including the clothes dryer. Now the house has been set up for maximum possibility for negative pressure.
7. Light and test the gas appliances one at a time for CO production. Since vented gas appliances also draw air from the house, leave them on after testing as the other appliances are tested to maintain a worst-case scenario.
8. If one of the gas appliances begins to create CO or its flue begins to back draft, there is a hazard potential. The best solution is to install an AGA-approved combustion air inlet system.
Here are some other tips to help you spot potentially hazardous situations:
Howard Leonard is president of Total Tech HVACR Training, Phoenix, AZ. His firm specializes in service, installation, and application training for service technicians. He can be reached at 602-943-2517.