Industry Sees RTUs Continue to Evolve
June 14, 2010
Things have greatly changed in technology over the last 10 years. And while rooftop units (RTUs) and commercial air handling units (AHUs) have been around much longer than a decade, they too, continue to change. The units persist in executing their original duties, but some of the features and benefits those units provide have altered over time.
One of the biggest changes in RTUs and AHUs over the last several years is the increase in efficiency of the units. “Because of rising energy costs, there has been interest in units with higher efficiencies. Manufacturers have responded by offering construction and components that raise efficiency levels,” said Robert G. Tanner, marketing manager for air-handling systems at Johnson Controls Inc.
A variety of features contribute to making units energy efficient, such as “air handlers with lower leakage rates, various types of energy recovery, and direct-drive air foil fans,” said Skip Ernst, applied air handling marketing manager for McQuay International.
Denise Ernst, director of commercial marketing for Lennox Industries Inc., remarked on other types of equipment that add to efficiency. “Motors are much more efficient, which has made an impact on energy usage, along with the introduction of multistaged equipment.”
INSTALLING, SERVICING MADE SIMPLEManufacturers have not only added more-efficient components, but have made RTU and AHU equipment easier to install and service, thus more efficient for contractors.
Ted Cherubin, product marketing manager for Carrier Corp.’s Light Commercial Division, indicated that more is being added to RTUs and AHUs at the factory than previously. “There has been a trend toward integrating more factory options that are pre-engineered and certified. Air management and energy-saving devices like economizers, energy recovery wheels, smoke detectors, and ‘change filter’ switches are some of the most popular options. Essentially, the industry has taken the packaged principle to the next level.”
“Many of the features that make the systems easier to install and service also makes the systems more reliable,” said Mike Ray, manager of light commercial development for Trane Residential Solutions, a division of Ingersoll Rand.
And reliability saves time and money for the contractors through a reduction in callbacks.
Saving contractors time on a jobsite makes a project more efficient for them as well.
“The number of factory-installed options is probably the biggest change [in the last several years]. In many cases, we can factory-install options such as economizers and smoke detectors faster and at a lower cost than a contractor in the field. This saves them both time and money,” said Steve Spires, commercial business leader for American Standard Heating & Air Conditioning.
Denise Ernst agrees. “We [manufacturers] are improving the energy efficiency of rooftop units, simplifying installation and providing proof of system performance with features that verify the units were installed correctly and are providing the benefits they’re designed to achieve.”
Ray pointed out that a faster installation not only benefits the contractor but the end user as well. By improving “the speed of the installation of a system, then the end user will be without air conditioning or heating for a shorter amount of time,” he said. “The same is true for serviceability: make it easier to service, and the service technicians will spend less time performing their job. This in turn could reduce the service cost to the end user.”
One concrete way manufacturers have done this is to produce units that can directly replace older units. Cherubin said, “Contractors have become increasingly concerned with the amount of time and the range of expertise required when installing replacements involving add-ons.” He commented that Carrier makes sure it offers packaged products that still fit on roof curbs from the late 1980s.
COMMERCIAL GREENThe rise in perceiving value in installing green units is making headway in the RTU and AHU sector. Skip Ernst said that greener rooftop units, ones “with better efficiency and LEED-friendly features,” are trending upward right now.
Leeanne Perkins, national advertising manager for Heat Controller Inc., also observed a growth in units that are more green. “The emphasis that we’ve seen in the residential sector on energy efficiency and indoor air quality will continue to expand into the commercial equipment market. This parallels increased awareness of and interest in sustainability and LEED-rated buildings.”
Various components contribute to green equipment even by being simple to clean thereby saving energy by running properly. An example is condensing coils which are “easier for the servicer to clean. Because the [Hybrid Coil™] coil is easier to clean, the unit maintains capacity and energy efficiency - which reduces energy use in comparison to a coil that does not get as thoroughly cleaned,” Ray said.
Manufacturers are looking to fans and motors to propel their RTUs and AHUs to even greater efficiencies and greening over the next few years than the units provide today. “The greener rooftops have better EER, often use microchannel condensers due to their superior heat transfer and robust construction, and [utilize] air foil indoor fans,” said Skip Ernst.
IAQ is another attribute that manufacturers see as one of the latest developments in commercial equipment. Tanner remarked that commercial air-handling units now have “tighter casing construction to reduce air leaking out, which hurts energy efficiency, or air leaking in, which hurts air cleanliness.”
WHAT THE FUTURE HOLDSThe rise in components that offer variability in speed, frequency, or the like also provide flexibility to applications. Among the current trends that Chuck Perry, commercial sales manager, Allied Air, Columbia, S.C., sees in RTUs and AHUs right now are variable-speed motors, variable-frequency drives, demand control ventilation, and IAQ.
Other features the industry will see inserted into more commercial units, according to Perkins, are “greater usage of ECM motors in HVAC equipment of all types, as well as variable-speed compressors. Microchannel coils may begin to replace the more traditional copper tube/aluminum fin coils.”
Perkins further stated that inverter technology will continue to spread from use in ductless mini-splits to other kinds of HVAC units. The technology “is proving so effective in reducing energy usage, while maintaining a high degree of comfort that we expect broader residential use, and then migration to other types of equipment, including commercial.”
Spires also foresees the increase in newer technologies in RTUs and AHUs. “I think we will continue to see increased focus on energy efficiency and indoor air quality. Variable-refrigerant flow and innovative fan motor technologies will play a large role in this,” he said.
The challenge for manufacturers is to be able to achieve efficiency without the associated bigger components, thus bigger equipment. Think of the concern a few years ago over increasing the coil size (thus the equipment size) to achieve the minimum 13 SEER ratings for residential air conditioning units.
The larger, weightier packaged equipment, according to Spires, will necessitate “expensive structural changes to the roof. This creates a need for innovation which will require new materials that can reduce the weight and maintain the current footprint of these units as efficiency requirements continue to increase.”
Perry also foresees RTUs and AHUs coming on the market in the next few years that have “smaller physical dimensions and [are] more efficient.”
“Overall, the story is efficiency, reliability, flexibility, and ease of use,” summed up Denise Ernst.
Publication date: 06/14/2010