The Professor: Comparing HFC-134a to R- 12
July 6, 2009
HFC-134a is the alternative refrigerant of choice to replace CFC-12 in many medium- and high-temperature stationary refrigeration and air conditioning applications. It has also replaced R-12 in automotive air conditioning applications. However, R-134a is not a direct drop-in refrigerant for R-12. Retrofit guidelines must be followed carefully when converting a system from R-12 to R-134a.
SAFETYIt is a very safe refrigerant and has a safety classification of A1. This means that it is not flammable and is very low on toxicity (See Figure 1). A classification of A1 is the safest, where a classification of B3 would be the most toxic and flammable.
MOLECULAR STRUCTURER-134a is not a refrigerant blend. It is considered a pure compound and has only one molecule present consisting of carbon (C), fluorine (F), and hydrogen (H) (See Figure 2).
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUESBecause R-134a has no chlorine in its molecule, it has a zero ozone depletion potential (ODP). Its global warming potential (GWP) is relatively low at 0.27.
TEMPERATURES, PRESSURESR-134a has a very similar pressure-temperature relationship when compared to R-12 (See Figure 3). However, at the lower temperature, R-134a has a bit lower pressures than R-12. Also, at higher temperatures, such as 65°F, R-134a has a bit lower pressure when compared to R-12. Otherwise, their pressure-temperature relationships closely compare.
CAPACITYBoth R-134a and R-12 have comparable capacity relationships (See Figure 4). When comparing capacities of R-134a to R-12, R-134a suffers some capacity loss when used as a low-temperature refrigerant. This can be a 6 percent capacity loss when compared to R-12 at the lower-temperature applications.
However, at the higher-temperature applications, there is a 6 percent increase in capacity when compared to R-12. Again, because of this phenomenon, R-134a is a good medium- and high-temperature refrigeration and air conditioning refrigerant.
It is not usually used in low-temperature applications. R-134a often operates with a very low pressure, if not a slight vacuum, at these lower temperatures.
EVAPORATOR TEMPERATURE APPLICATIONAt about a -15°F evaporating temperature, R-134a starts to fall into a vacuum. These lower pressures at the lower temperature application cause higher compression ratios and low efficiencies, not to mention the added stress put on the system’s compressor.
LUBRICANTStationary R-134a systems use synthetic polyolester (POE) lubricants. The automotive industry uses polyalkylene glycol (PAG) lubricants with R-134a. R-134a is insoluble, and thus incompatible, with mineral oils used in many refrigeration and air conditioning applications today.
Publication Date: 07/06/2009